Last Updated: February 25, 2026 — Reviewed by Brian Hayes, Licensed Master Plumber
Your toilet may be one of the most overlooked yet overused fixture in your bathroom. Most homeowners go on using the same toilet for several years for as long as nothing breaks.
Your toilet deserves some love and attention, too. Although they are pretty durable, they are not meant to last forever. To help you decide whether you need to replace your toilet or not, we have made a list of telltale signs that should tell you if its time to shop around. Find out more by reading on below.
Broken parts and components
Your toilet is made of a number of components that may break and cause costly damages if left unrepaired. If you find that a certain component is not behaving the way it should, call a plumber.
Your plumber can give you a more accurate determination whether a certain component can still be salvaged or not.
Leaks for days
Leaks are too wasteful and costly for you to ignore. You might think “A tiny leak won’t hurt!” but that is not true. A tiny leak today can take a toll on your utility bill and ultimately cause your entire toilet to break and malfunction unexpectedly.
It is best that you act on even the tiniest leak by calling a plumber. If leaks become persistent, you might want to consider shopping around for a new toilet.
Appearance
Your toilet takes a heavy amount of beating on a daily basis – it is only natural for its appearance to dull due to age. If your toilet is becoming more of an eyesore instead of a useful fixture to have around, do not hesitate to start looking for a replacement.
Water efficiency
Your toilet consumes a lot of water on a daily basis. Older models tend to use more water compared to newer ones. If you had the toilet around for a while, there is a huge chance it is using up more water than it should.
Replacing your toilet with a newer model may be costly upfront but can save you a whole lot of cash in the long run – a water efficient toilet is a good investment if you ask us.
When it comes to your toilet, functionality should be a top priority. If your toilet is not working the way it should or is costing you more simply by doing what it is suppose to do, then you might want to invest in a replacement.
Replacing your toilet today can earn you huge savings down the road and will instantly make your bathroom appear cleaner and brighter.
Are you thinking about replacing your toilet? Give us a call today. Our experts will be more than happy to help you find the right model for your needs. At Hayes Plumbing, we put your needs on top of our priorities. Give us a call TODAY!
Additional Resources
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does toilet repair cost in Oshawa?
The cost of toilet repair in Oshawa varies depending on the scope of work, materials selected, and bathroom size. Hayes Plumbing provides free in-home estimates throughout Durham Region so you know exactly what to expect before any work begins.
How long does toilet repair take to complete?
Most toilet repair projects in Durham Region take between 2 and 4 weeks depending on the complexity and material lead times. Hayes Plumbing coordinates all trades to keep your project on schedule.
Do I need a permit for toilet repair in Ontario?
In Ontario, you typically need a building permit if your toilet repair project involves structural changes or moving plumbing lines. Hayes Plumbing can advise whether your specific project requires a permit from the City of Oshawa.
Need help with your bathroom renovation? Hayes Plumbing & Bathroom Renovations serves Oshawa, Ajax, Whitby, Clarington, and Pickering. Contact us or call (905) 576-3043 for a free estimate.
